One thing I get asked a lot on courses I run is about how I structure my NCEA music classes. If a typical NCEA subject consists of 22-24 credits some teachers are a little incredulous when they hear I offer 53 credits at level 2 and 64 credits at level 3.
The first thing I point out is that it’s not as bad as it sounds as students don’t take all those credits (although I have had one student that did… but he was a rare sort of student as he went on to get NZ’s top Music Scholarship mark in 2013) and even if they are taking around 38-44 credits, up to 16 of those credits could be performance ‘standards’, which we don’t spend any class time on (they do all their learning for this with their instrumental teacher and assessment takes place in concerts).
However, with the majority of my year 13 students doing Project Based Learning this year the whole NCEA credit thing and course structure has become a little more complicated. In some ways it’s not… in that they’ve chosen the sort of project they want to do (such making an album, or composing for film projects produced by the Year 13 Media/Film class) and the available NCEA Standards should take care of themselves. But with a dozen or so students all doing different projects, assessment within the NCEA structure can be hard to keep on top of and regularly fills my sleepless nights with worry!
I’ve got one student who as a result of her student leadership position in the school is struggling to keep on top of her workload. We are now almost halfway through the 2nd term of school (only 4-5 weeks away from halfway point in the year) and I haven’t seen any substantial work from her yet. It’s clear that she is going to struggle to complete her task of producing a singer/songwriter type album by November unless we find something to motivate.
So this week, we’ve done a review – something I’m finding hugely necessary to keep the students on top of workload and to keep them focused (I’m trying to sit down with each student at least once every two weeks).
What we have done this week with this student is what I believe is the secret to offering lots of NCEA credits – assessing multiple standards from few tasks. Let’s be clear, it’s not double dipping, it’s about designing smart tasks that have multiple aspects to the work flow that can fit in with the requirements of multiple standards at once. What I’m finding with PBL is that the tasks need to be personalised to the individual student. This is the task we’ve designed for her:
- She has recently developed a real interest in Gospel Music (as a result of what she’s singing in the school choir) and wants to do a research project on it. She hasn’t narrowed her line of inquiry yet but it’ll be something along the lines of looking at the importance of Gospel music to African-American slaves on the cotton fields and how their harmonies developed… through to how Gospel music continues to influence the harmonies/style of modern R’n’B styles of music.
- She will do her research and present it but a major part of the presentation will be arranging a piece of music in a Gospel style, using the knowledge that she will develop through her research. She will produce notation of her arrangement which she’ll annotate for the purposes of the research presentation. She may even produce two arrangements of two different types of Gospel arrangements with different instrumentation.
- She will also produce a recording/sequence of her piece of music using knowledge she’s developed using Presonus Studio One and/or Reaper.
- If we take this further, she may even perform one or two of her arrangements in a performance evening for solo or group performance (but this is less likely as she has plenty of material to use from her singing lessons).
So, from this one task which she is hugely motivated to achieve will result in the following NCEA credits:
- 3.10 Research standard – 6 credits
- 3.9 Arranging standard – 4 credits
- 23730 sequencing and notation standard – 8 credits
- TOTAL – 18 credits
If you add her solo and group performance Standards of 12 credits she has a course of 30 credits, which is plenty! If she was doing the 28007 (SOND 3) recording standard, which could easily be incorporated if she had the time to do the learning for it, she would have another 6 credits.
If you’d like to follow her progress as she works through this project you can follow her blog here:
Thanks, Duncan 🙂
One thought on “Project Based Learning in music – part 3”
Thanks for sharing this Duncan. We work like this too and it certainly improves student achievement. Keep up the great work!